Tuesday, 17 March 2015

Comic workshop in India


What follows is a report produced by comic workshop leaders, Anna Pesonen-Smith & Christopher Smith in March 2015. The report is part of the Comic as a Method of Multicultural Pedagogy course that we attended through Tampere Summer University in the autumn of 2014.

Introduction

On Thursday the 19th of February 2015 we (Anna Pesonen-Smith and Christopher Smith) held a Comic as a Method of Multicultural Pedagogy workshop for a class of 13 to 15-year-olds at an all-girl school in India. The school fees are nominal and the pupils come from disadvantaged backgrounds.

The reasons for holding the workshop were threefold; firstly, in order to complete the Tampere Summer University course we had attended the previous autumn in Finland, secondly, to help give the girls a platform for telling their own stories and voicing their own concerns in their own community and thirdly, for us to have the experience of holding such a workshop.

What follows is an account of how we prepared for the workshop, what happened during the session and finally, our reflections on the outcomes and challenges of the workshop.


Planning the workshop

Anna having previously met with the school principal in 2008, we already had a tentative contact in place with which to use for making the arrangements for the workshop during our two-week long stay in Calcutta. On Monday the 16th of February we visited the school, met with the principal and informed her of our proposal to hold a three-hour long workshop aimed at giving the children the chance to produce their own wall comics which explored social issues of their own choosing. We provided her with some background information about the World Comics project and our own pedagogical studies in Finland.

The principal agreed to our plan but put a cap of two-and-a-half hours on the workshop, rather than the three we asked for. We enquired about the English language capabilities of the pupils and were told that they would not speak English well, but that there would be one or two of the school’s teachers on hand to aid us. Regarding the number of pupils, it was informed later that there would be approximately 25 of them, which roughly fell within our understood remit or 12 per workshop leader. On the day there turned out to be 23 pupils and two assisting teachers.


Equipment

As a thank you to the school and to the participants, we offered to supply all the relevant equipment needed for the workshop and leave it behind with the school and children afterwards. We patronized a small local stationary shop, buying the requisite amount of pencils, felt-tip pens, sharpeners, rubbers and paper.

We had brought with us the templates needed for the practice and final drawing, as well as English language guides as supplied to us during our own workshop in Finland. Again, we used a local copy shop and made enough copies of those templates as well as an additional workshop guide to be left with the school in case they would be interested in conducting the course again in future. 

Then we made a list of the content of the workshop, from introductions to final group photograph and allocated what we felt was hopefully adequate time for each activity. We also divided up the tasks, so that Anna would lead some sections and Chris would lead others. Whilst one was leading, the other would either help distribute materials or document the proceedings by taking pictures on the iPhone.


Holding the workshop

Knowing  that time was limited, we tried to be as much as possible to both strict with ourselves and the pupils about not lingering too much, as well as flexible about readjusting the allocated times as and when it appeared absolutely necessary.

Our first task was to introduce ourselves and at the same time, get a sense of the pupils’ English capabilities. It became clear immediately that their English was for the most part at such a rudimentary level that we would have to lean on the two local teachers to help translate and clarify what we were doing.

At this stage we understood that it would have been so easy to get sidetracked by talking about Finland or ourselves, but we stuck to the task at hand and barrelled on into the comic workshop.

The first task for the pupils was for them to divide into smaller groups and come up with a few social issues that they see around them that they care about. We took great care to not suggest any examples, so as not to lead them in any specific direction. After a couple of minutes, we started going round the groups collecting their ideas and we wrote them on the board for everyone to see. The ideas ranged in scale from very local issues (for example, the lack of a school bus) to much wider issues that affect the whole of Indian society (such as child labour).



We realized that using the assisting teachers as translators, whilst a necessity, also had its drawbacks. The teachers themselves seemed at times unwilling to communicate fully and immediately to us the pupils’ social issue examples. One pupil wanted to raise the issue of there being no water available and the teacher, after some deliberation, informed us that the pupil said there was no water sometimes with very heavy emphasis on the “sometimes”. It wasn’t clear that this was exactly what the pupil was saying. The only thing understood by us was that she was using the world “water” both in Hindi and Bengali.

Having constructed the list of issues, we distributed blank paper and asked the pupils to make a large cross and, choosing one topic, start creating a story about that topic in four parts, though just with language. A couple of the pupils were able at this stage to write in English their ideas. The rest wrote in Bengali and we had the teachers translate for us. In order to help them understand this idea, we chose one of their topics, the lack of a school bus, and demonstrated how that could be turned into a story. A few pupils copied this idea with varying degrees of personalization.

It became clear at this stage that there would be a wide range in quality of the stories coming from the group and also that it would be difficult in the time-limited circumstances and with the language challenges, to perform adequate and fairly distributed quality checks. However, we did our best and aimed to mobilize those pupils who were more advanced to help those around them lacking in ideas or ability.




Next we gave a short How To Draw tutorial, demonstrating how to turn a stick-man into a more fully-realized human shape as well as how to convey basic human emotions through drawing facial expressions. We didn’t have time to let the pupils practice this, so they had to jump in at the deep end and start drawing their stories in the small-format templates we provided.

Having created their drawing concepts, we moved them on to recreating them in the final, large format templates, first in pencil and then eventually in ink, whilst adding titles and their own names to the sheets. Taping them together and fast running out of time, we came to the end of a hectic two-and-a-half hours with everyone having a completed wall comic.


Results

As stated above, the quality of the comics ranged from incredibly interesting, socially relevant, well-told and well-drawn to utterly lacking in story or representation to the point that there it was questionable whether the pupil understood what had been happening during the workshop but had at least had some fun drawing some characters on paper.

The workshop being held in the afternoon meant that when the bell rang for the end, the students finished their own school day and quickly became keen to leave for their own adventures. This meant we were unable to have a clear feedback session where the pupils would look at the work and discuss it. Given the language challenges, this would anyway have taken a very long time to implement. Some pupils left with their own comics and others left them to the classroom. Those ones in the classroom we could right away hand over to the principal who promised to display them in the school as part of an exhibition. Those pupils who took their comics home would be requested to bring them back so they could be added to the exhibition.



We received feedback from the teachers, pupils and the school principal that the workshop had been a surprising success, that the pupils enjoyed it and that it would even be nice to have something similar in future, through for a longer period. One of the teachers stated that she would be happy to use the comic drawing method in her English classes.


Reflections

Our own experience of hosting the workshop was one of excitement, mayhem, productivity and fun. It was ultimately very rewarding. Below are some remarks about lessons learned from our side concerning holding a workshop such as this.
 
Two-and-a-half hours isn’t enough. Three would be better, but also tight. Then one has to think about how much stamina and attentions the participants have if it would be longer than three hours.

Keeping a balance of strictness with the time as well as some flexibility on the move was essential for this to have worked as well as it did.

23 pupils who almost all don’t have the requisite English skills is a massive task for two workshop leaders. In order to perform adequate quality control, half that amount would have been better.

Whilst having someone to translate might sometimes be necessary, vetting or preparing the translator beforehand would also be useful, to reduce the risk of them filtering what the students are saying.

Keeping a positive attitude during the whole process is essential. If one starts to become stressed or frustrated, it can easily become sensed by the pupils and they will become less at ease. We feel we were able to do this well.

Conducting the workshop as a pair was very nice. Having someone else to share tasks, support and consult with during the process was incredibly useful.

We would be happy to run this kind of workshop again.


Thursday, 15 January 2015

Teaching practice finished

I have now completed my teaching practice at TAMK.

You can check out what I have to say about that here, as well as going directly to the blog that I created for the course I taught, on Narrative Game Making with Twine, the open-source game engine.

All I have to do now is prepare my final report on the teaching practice practical section and then I'm all done with it!


Wednesday, 19 November 2014

Teaching observation, Day Five

Today was the last day of my teaching observation period and I had the pleasure of sitting in on the Introduction to Animation class for the first year Fine Arts students. As always, if you click here and scroll through al the other amazingly interesting day recaps, you'll eventually get to Day Five.

Here's an early short animation that was shown today as part of the class, just to keep things interesting. It's about a dinosaur, so what's not to like?!


Tuesday, 18 November 2014

Teaching observation, Day Four

Today I attended the penultimate session of my teaching observation period at TAMK, this time sitting in on one of my own subjects, which was different. Like always, you can click here and scroll down to get all the details.

For adding colour, I include now a video of The Hero's Journey from the people at Extra Credits:


Monday, 17 November 2014

Teaching observation, Day Three

Into the second week and the third day of teaching observation. Today I sat in on the continuation of the Introduction to Animation course, but now with a different teacher, which helped new things come to my mind. What new things?! You can see here if you scroll down a bit to Day Three.

Here's a making of video about Coraline, a wonderful stop-motion animation that was created using Dragonframe, the program the students were learning today...






Friday, 14 November 2014

The Comic - Part Two

Last week we completed the classroom course work for the Comic as a Method for Multicultural Pedagogy, which was two days, the 30th of October and the 5th of November. You can read all about that in the Comic course dairy page, though you'll have to laboriously scroll down past the first two days to get to those exciting last two days. But it's worth it. You can see here.

And here's a comic I drew:

And here's a better comic, that I didn't draw:


The course isn't finished yet, we still have to host our own comic course using the methodology we learnt, which I will do with Anna, hopefully in early December.

Thursday, 13 November 2014

Teaching observation, Day Two

The second day of my teaching observation took me to the Demola mid-pitch event at the Finlayson site in central Tampere. If you want to know how that went and what I thought about it, check out the Day Two section in the Practice page of this blog. You have to scroll down a little for it.


Monday, 10 November 2014

Teaching observation, Day One

Today I began my teaching observation at TAMK, sitting in on the Introduction to Animation class which was looking at making anthropomorphized characters from animals as well as animating using After Effects. You can see my incredibly insightful thoughts from Day One here.


Wednesday, 8 October 2014

Evaluating LinkedIn as a tool for education



TAMK Participatory Learning & Teaching - Assignment: Networking with LinkedIn

With over 300 million users (40% of whom check in daily) in over 200 countries, LinkedIn is one of the social networking success stories. Unlike Facebook or Twitter, however, LinkedIn sets its stall out as a venue for career-related networking, rather than socializing in general. 




In the digital age, educators are keen to harness the powers of this phenomenon for their own ends. But before doing so, they must ask themselves two questions: What is it good for? And, what are the drawbacks? Let’s first have a look at the upsides:

Networking

The value of networking is clear for all to see, especially in education at a vocational level and higher where students will be searching for work practice placements and potential future employment. Knowing the right people helps.

The old models of networking are not only disappearing but can feel painfully cumbersome to maintain. At its most basic level, LinkedIn allows students and educators to connect and keep in touch. It’s a tool with a purpose and it is able to perform its purpose well when used correctly.

Internationality

Using LinkedIn can help educators to bridge otherwise significant distance problems with foreign partners. Whilst there’s little excuse for not visiting your colleagues or counterparts in your own town, the financial limitations of doing so internationally, as well as time and energy costs, mean that LinkedIn is a useful tool in meeting that challenge.

Unknown possibilities

One of the truly useful aspects of LinkedIn for students is that they can gain knowledge of career paths that they may never have thought of before. Through linking with new people in different sectors and putting themselves out there, they can find unexpected opportunities.

Online CV

The most basic use of LinkedIn is as an online CV. Users are able to include information in their profiles about skills, competences, work experience, education, projects and aspirations for the future. Importantly for a CV, it’s simple to keep up to date. Creating a portfolio is a necessity for most students and LinkedIn not only helps you do this, but also provides eyeballs for looking at it.

What are the downsides of using LinkedIn?

Despite the impressive growth of the site, there exists polarizing opinions about its worth. Let’s have a look at some of the key drawbacks in using LinkedIn for education.

Procrastination

A survey conducted by Salary.com found that for all the reasons people waste time at work (let’s annex study onto this, too), by far the biggest culprit was social networking, including LinkedIn. This raises the question of why people are time wasting in the first place. That can be due to many factors, though lack of motivation would seem to cover a lot of those.  

Arguably, social networks may be a symptom rather than a cause of time wasting, but one thing is for sure, they don’t help.

Conformity

People are generally at best unmoved by mass-produced online profiles and at worst mistrustful of them. For students looking to make an impression on prospective study or workplaces, being able to point to a LinkedIn profile is unlikely to get anyone’s pulse racing. Never underestimate the worth of standing out.

Privacy

Putting your personal information into the hands of a business means you lose control of it. The Terms of Service for LinkedIn state that they have unlimited license to sell user information to anyone. Below is a quote from their website:

…you grant LinkedIn a nonexclusive, irrevocable, worldwide, perpetual, unlimited, assignable, sublicenseable, fully paid up and royalty-free right to … use and commercialize, in any way now known or in the future discovered, any information you provide, directly or indirectly to LinkedIn … without any further consent, notice and/or compensation to you or to any third parties.

The old adage comes to mind, ‘If you are using something for free on the internet, you are the product.’

Would we suggest other educational tools if they could potentially endanger the privacy rights of the students?

Exclusivity

Whilst it may seem that the level of participation in online networking among young people is reaching saturation point, it will simply never be the case that every student or educator will be happy to sign up. 

This results in an imbalanced playing field, where most people are happy to go along with the service and some, for better or worse reasons, are not. Those students left behind are potentially disadvantaged for it.

Summary

LinkedIn, and any similar online networking tool, is optimally used as a supplement for real world networking and certainly not as a complete substitute. 

The world of education has not yet entirely shifted into the cyberspace and it’s not going to any time soon. People value meeting in person and the danger is that if there is a backlash against social networking, some people entering the workforce will lack the social skills needed for real world interactions. 

To lean on the internet as the key medium for education is to employ a rather wobbly crutch.

Of course, students themselves mostly opt into studies through their own volition and if it’s clear from the start that the course involves participation in a social networking site, then that’s all fair and well. If, however, it isn’t presented front and centre then a certain amount of flexibility has to be in place to accommodate those students unwilling to sign up.

Sources

ColourMyLearning.com

Forbes

Salary.com

The Tech Republic

LinkedIn statistics

LinkedIn Terms of Service